Copying to Learn: When Your Artwork Isn’t Yours to Sign
Following on from last week, here is when not to sign your work.
Learning to paint or draw often involves copying the work of masters or using photographs provided by a tutor. It’s a valuable, time-honoured method for developing technique. However, there is a critical legal and ethical line you must never cross: you cannot sign or sell work that copies someone else’s copyrighted material.
When is a Copy Not Your Original Work?
If you reproduce another artist’s painting or a photographer’s image, the resulting piece is a derivative work. The copyright for the original composition remains with the creator of that source material. Signing your name to it is not just bad practice; it can be legally considered forgery.
This is true even if:
- Your teacher provided the photo for you to copy;
- You spent countless hours perfecting it; and/or
- You changed the colours or cropped the image.
The underlying creative work – the composition – is not yours. You have exercised skill in reproduction, but you have not created an original piece of intellectual property.
A Real-World Warning
I know an artist who copied photos supplied by her teacher. When challenged, she argued that because she painted them, she owned them. She is wrong. She went on to sell the work, profiting from the teacher’s copyrighted material. While in this case the teacher chose not to pursue it, the legal and professional risks were significant.
How to Learn Ethically:
- Copy for Practice: By all means continue to copy! It’s one of the best ways to learn. Study the brushwork, the light, the composition.
- Do Not Sign These Pieces: Clearly mark them as “After [Artist’s Name]” or “Study of [Artist’s Name]” on the back. This shows respect and clarifies the work’s purpose.
- Never Sell Them: Selling a copied work without the original creator’s express permission is an infringement of copyright and a serious breach of artistic ethics.
- Use Your Own References: The safest path is to paint from life or from photographs you have taken yourself.
Respecting copyright protects you from legal action and upholds the integrity of the artistic community. Create your own original work and sign that with pride.
NB I do not get paid to endorse any people or brands mentioned in my blogs. If you enjoyed this post, please like, share and follow me. Sharing, liking and following raises the algorithms in my favour.
Thank you for your support.